Sepulcher Rights Lawsuits in NY
What is the Right of Sepulcher?
The "right of sepulcher" dates back hundreds of years in common
law. The right of sepulcher is the right to choose and control the burial,
cremation, or other final disposition of a human body. Under New York
state law, the next of kin of a decedent can commence a lawsuit for a
violation of his or her right of sepulcher when a next of kin's right
to immediate possession of a decedent's body is interfered with, and
the interference causes mental anguish.
Interference with one's right of sepulcher can arise under the following
- Unauthorized autopsy
- Inadvertent disposition of remains
- Failure to notify next of kin of the death
In New York, the disposition of remains is governed by Public Health Law
§ 4201; and that “[a]bsent a valid written instrument appointing
an agent for that purpose, section 4201 sets forth which individuals shall
have priority to make decisions concerning the disposition of remains.”
Exceptions to the Right of Sepulcher
The common-law right of sepulcher cannot infringe upon the expansive authority
of the Medical Examiner's Office to discharge its duties in the exercise
of its professional discretion. A medical examiner or coroner has the
statutory authority to perform autopsies under certain specified circumstances,
including any situations that suggest that death occurred:
- By criminal violence
- By accident
- By suicide
- Suddenly when in apparent health
- When unattended by a physician
- In any suspicious or unusual manner
New York City's Chief Medical Examiner and his or her designees are
also expressly authorized to conduct forensic testing, perform pathology,
histology, and toxicology testing, and to determine the cause of injuries
and/or death. They are further required to notify the appropriate district
attorney when, in the judgment of the particular medical examiner, criminality
or foul play is indicated. The authority to perform such tests necessarily
includes, by implication, the authority to remove organs, tissue samples,
and bodily fluids for that specific purpose.
How Flanzig & Flanzig, LLP Can Help
At Flanzig & Flanzig, LLP, we have handled several high-profile loss
of sepulcher rights cases. These include the well-known case of the wrongful
and negligent disposition of our clients prematurely born baby, which
was lost by the hospital and discovered in the commercial laundry. We
filed suit against South Nassau Communities Hospital on behalf of the mother.
The matter was eventually tried to a six-figure verdict in the Nassau County
In another matter, we obtained a significant recovery against the City
of New York for the failure to notify the family of the death of a loved
one. By failing to conduct a proper search, the body was wrongfully buried
on Hart Island despite the fact that the family, who lived in the tri-state
area, would have taken possession and arrange for a proper family burial.
As a result of the failure of the City and the Medical Examiner's
office to notify the family the body was placed in a mass grave at Hart
Island and ultimately discovered there by the family months later.
An another potential example is a matter where we represented a Brooklyn
family in a claim against the New York City Medical Examiner’s Office,
Kings County Hospital and City of New York due to the negligent handling
of her deceased son's body.
If you feel that you may have a claim for a violation of sepulcher rights,
call us for a free case evaluation. You can
contact us at night or even over the weekend at 888-290-5994.
We serve clients and their families throughout the five boroughs, and areas
in Suffolk and Nassau Counties.